TRANSCRIBED AND TRANSLATED MEDIA Mix of Ukraininan channels

Visa filmarkiv

Weapons of the 80s that changed the course of the war: Patriot – the world is fighting for this SAM system again, and what does Ukraine have to do with it?

The Patriot missile system has regained its reputation through successful interceptions in Ukraine, particularly against Kinzhal missiles, despite previous criticisms and its aging hardware architecture.


Speaker 2

A Cold War-era dinosaur. A digital Frankenstein or a billion-dollar sledgehammer.

Speaker 1

Now it is hard to believe, but just four years ago, many American experts mercilessly criticized the Patriot anti-aircraft missile system. The system was called outdated, clumsy, overrated, and incapable of shooting down modern missiles. Everything was changed by the war in Ukraine, where the Patriots once again showed themselves in all their glory. And they also showed Europe's dependence on the States and the need to create its own anti-ballistic shield. Heated disputes regarding the Patriots lasted for two decades, since the beginning of the 2000s. The Pentagon set about creating another system, then launched a project for a new missile, but the cost of new developments was simply astronomical. So the Americans decided it would be more efficient to upgrade existing missiles and systems. And they were not mistaken. The reputation of the Patriots was saved specifically in Ukraine. In 2022, skepticism still prevailed in the US Military Academies. However, just a year later, the skill of Ukrainian operators and engineers proved that Patriot is still relevant.

Speaker 2

There is no target, or practically no target, that the Patriot cannot engage. That is exactly why it is so in-demand at this moment. And that is why it is needed all over the world. Additionally, all of this was compounded by America's war against Iran. Because the Iranians used a large number of ballistic missiles against Israel, against Saudi Arabia, and even against the United Arab Emirates. Therefore, it really is a very good development, despite the fact that it is relatively complex in terms of time parameters.

Speaker 1

It was the successes of the Patriot in countering Russian missiles that not only finally dispelled all doubts about the system's effectiveness but also triggered a real boom in orders. The turning point was specifically the shoot-down of a Kinzhal over Kyiv on May 4, 2023. The event became a sensation. Unique telemetric data from a real combat interception, which cannot be obtained at any proving ground, were passed to the Pentagon. Until then, many Western analysts believed that shooting down a Kinzhal was impossible due to its high speed and the extraordinary strength of its fuselage and warhead. Therefore, detonating an anti-rocket near the target in hopes of damaging it with fragments might not have worked. Instead, the PAC-3 literally rammed the Kinzhal head-on. The success of the "Hit to kill" concept—kinetic interception—showed that the modernization of the Patriots was a surprisingly far-sighted decision. The Russians themselves also greatly contributed to the triumph of the American system. For years, they created a myth of a "wonder weapon" around the Kinzhal. Besides the usual "analogue-ness," they also spoke of an invincible hypersonic capability—the missile's ability to actively maneuver at all stages of flight. In 2018, Putin stated that the Kinzhal is invincible against all existing and prospective anti-missile and anti-aircraft defense systems. But the very first combat encounter put everything in its place. Adding piquancy to the Russian fiasco was the fact that they used their wonder weapon to hunt specifically for Patriots. Later, American officials confirmed that that night the Kinzhal's target was not an infrastructure object, but the surface-to-air missile system itself. However, the Ukrainian crew reacted instantly and shot down the missile. The Patriot is not just a legend of air defense, but a true technical phenomenon. The main feature, of course, is the interception method, when the interceptor missile literally rams the target to destroy the warhead. However, kinetic interception is not the only way the Patriot can impress.

Speaker 2

It is in the fact that the uniqueness of the Patriot. It has a very high-quality radar. It can detect targets up to 600 kilometers. And the characteristic of this radar is that it does not rotate. It is stationary – this is a very high-quality technological breakthrough of the American military school. And when this radar captures a target, the missile is designed in such a way that it operates by radio command. That is, it is told where it should fly and how it should fly. But it also has its own small radar. That is, it actually captures and guides the target, well, almost down to one centimeter. That is, when several of these missiles – four, five, six, or if necessary, sixteen – are launched simultaneously, the target is doomed, regardless of what it is. Plus, there is another very great uniqueness of the Patriot. It is true that the ptiy also has it in the configuration of the Astr-30 missile, but the Americans truly implemented it. What is it? It is a plane-parallel displacement from the missile itself. Now I will explain what this is in layman's terms. We are riding a bicycle and we need to turn. So we ride, ride, ride, we need to go left, right, it doesn't matter, we turn the handlebars and an arc is formed, or if necessary, we turn around. And now imagine that there is some technology where we are riding and in a fraction of a second we can sharply shift to the right, we can sharply shift to the left. And as far as the missile is concerned, practically at any point in the space around the missile, there are up to 180 pyrotechnic cartridges or gas generators. And when the target is moving, moving quickly, changing its trajectory, the missile can receive a command for a very sharp change.

Speaker 1

Patriot is deservedly called the best in its class. In countering ballistics, it truly has no equal on the planet. But why, then, was the system called a digital Frankenstein? The latest modifications of the system use the newest PAC-3 missiles and advanced algorithms. However, at the hardware level, electronic boards and cables from the distant 80s still exist within the system's architecture – this is a legacy of the system's history.

Speaker 2

This weapon was born as a result of three wars of the twentieth century – 1967, the so-called Six-Day War of Israel against the Arab coalition, then the American-Vietnamese war, which in general chronological terms lasted within 15 years, and in this same cycle, because these are the same time parameters – 1972, this is the Yom Kippur War, when the Arab coalition tried to reclaim the Sinai, but in the end, the Israelis won this war in a military sense. So, it was then, when jet aircraft had already been born, and in opposition to them, surface-to-air missile systems were born to shoot down these aircraft, and this great experience began to be born. This is a separate topic to analyze everything. We will not have enough time; literally briefly, where the Patriot grew from.

The question arose that a truly good system was needed, which, first and foremost, would shoot down aviation. And this is the first system that began to be developed as early as the mid-70s, and fully entered service in the 80s. And this, what was before the mid-80s, is the PAC-1 configuration. PAC-2. Serious ballistics already appear, cruise missiles already appear, everything-everything-everything is developing. Strategic rivals, both the USA and the Soviet Union, follow each other and work to stay ahead. They think about how all this needs to be shot down. And indeed, the Patriot experienced its combat baptism in 1991. This is the war in the Persian Gulf, where Iraq occupied Kuwait, but at the same time, Iraq in its existential sense chose Israel as its target and launched at least 40 R-17 "Elbrus" missiles toward Israel. This is a quite good Soviet development, which could have up to a ton of explosives in its warhead, and also Iraqi forces quite seriously considered placing a chemical warhead there; a quite high-speed missile within 6,000 km per hour, quite heavy, up to 6 tons.

And that is where the Patriot first worked in the PAC-2 part. What is the PAC-2 part? The missile itself is fragmentation-high explosive, meaning the missile approaches the target that needs to be destroyed. That is, a special command is given, it explodes, a huge cloud of fragments is formed—by the way, the exact number is classified to this day. And these fragments weigh between 2 to 45 grams and the target itself is neutralized.

But there is a very large discussion here; in truth, it needs to be explained, because we are moving to the moment when PAC-3 appears. Practically all "Scud" missiles—by NATO classification, R-17 "Elbrus"—were neutralized. I am expressing very correctly that they were neutralized. Why exactly so? When this whole cloud exploded, and everything is moving fast, the attack payload itself is moving, in our case the R-17 "Elbrus," and the missile is moving. They diverge from each other in milliseconds, and when that which fell was later studied, it is seen that the warhead was not touched. It destroyed either where the fuel tanks were, or where the engine itself was. But the warhead could have reached, true, no longer the target, but could have reached a certain radius and exploded. And so specialists still argue whether this is a success or not a success. Or, if we understand that the MIM-104 "Patriot" in the PAC-2 configuration consists of four launch containers, they always launched two-three, or even four missiles. The first one hit, and the other three flew past. Is this a success or not a success? And they came to the conclusion that they need to work so seriously that there would be guaranteed destruction, first and foremost, of ballistics.

Speaker 1

And they performed with utmost seriousness. The new generation of PAC-3 interceptors demonstrated an almost hundred percent result against Iranian ballistics in 2003. Since its first appearance on the battlefield, the "Patriot" has undergone a long path of modernization. After rigorous trials in Ukraine, no one had even the slightest doubts regarding its effectiveness. But criticism does not subside, which, in truth, is for entirely different reasons.

Speaker 2

Several myths need to be dispelled, very fundamental and very widespread, about the number of launchers and the number of missiles as such. That, supposedly, there are not enough of them, they are few, and so on. I do not share this opinion. The Americans, just the Americans themselves, have between 800 and 900 systems; the data varies slightly. And this is despite the fact that not everything is on combat duty; some is in warehouses. Overall, since the system began production, up to 1,300 units of the launchers alone have been produced; in Saudi Arabia, there are at least 150 of them, and of missiles of various configurations—I emphasize, various configurations—at least 10,000 units have been produced. This is despite the fact that, for example, a country like Japan has a license to manufacture this missile. Therefore, unfortunately, everything once again comes down to politics and geopolitics. The Americans are in no hurry to transfer them to us. Indeed, there is a discussion, a very serious discussion, that, supposedly, we have already learned to intercept with drones; some air attack means agree that it is, conventionally, impractical to shoot with an expensive Patriot missile, which costs between 3 and 4 million dollars, and, for example, against the same Shahed—from 1936 asaudity—doing this was absolutely impractical, but not agreeing with the philosophy that one should not buy expensive weaponry. Yes, the MIM-104 Patriot launcher itself costs around 200 million dollars. If we understand that a battery consists of 4-6 launchers, it is incredibly expensive. And if we understand that the radar itself, and most importantly the brain, the brain of the battery where the calculations take place, is also quite complex equipment, then it carries a certain monetary equivalent. However, for a concrete example, for understanding, in the longest war the US has ever waged in its history, the US war against the Taliban movement in Afghanistan from 2001 to 2021, they spent 2-3 million dollars. And, interestingly, neither American society nor the American economy felt this practically at all.

Speaker 1

Another reason for criticism is that producing interceptor components is time-consuming and complex. The technological cycle for creating a single PAC-3 missile takes a long two years. Inside one such unit are 400 different parts. A natural question arises: could this assembly line not have been simplified to start stamping out missiles much faster?

Speaker 2

This is because it is a very, very complex system. Let us not fall into the sin of reductionism. What is the sin of reductionism? It is a simplification [to speak of] weapons of this order. There are an incredibly large number of such details, primarily microelectronics. But we must also understand a very important aspect: you cannot just put an ordinary fitter or an ordinary turner, who might even turn, say, some piston for a car, to work specifically in the production of such equipment. This is specialized equipment where people need to be trained and everything needs to be calibrated. It is time, time, and time once again. And, say, in the American context, because this is very important, it is also potentially pension provision. Because it is not like it is for us in the Soviet space, where a tank plant received an order in 2018. The order is so serious and large, workers go to work in three shifts, working again in shifts for a week, and then there are no orders, the plant stops, everyone goes home, but they remain on the payroll. It doesn't work that way there. There, if a plant is started, if it is supposed to operate, especially in the defense sector, everything is calculated decades in advance. That is why all of this takes so long. But the flywheels are in motion, the company "Raytheon" is slowly but surely increasing the production quantity of missiles. In my view, they have now reached somewhere around the limit, within the limit of 800 units per year, although I believe it is actually significantly more, because there is such a thing as information noise. In principle, no one is actually supposed to know how much and exactly what kind of such weapons are being produced.

Speaker 1

Americans are in no hurry to share missiles. On October 30, the US State Department approved the sale of 500 Patriot missiles to Ukraine. Europeans and Canada are paying 2.1 billion dollars. It sounds like a victory, but there is a nuance. These missiles do not exist. They still need to be manufactured. And according to Reuters data, they will arrive only in the early 2030s. But ballistic missiles need to be intercepted right now. On October 15, CNN, citing a source, writes that Patriot missiles in Ukraine have run out. And on the eve, Russian ballistic missiles brutally shelled Kyiv. Naturally, a logical question. Can we produce Patriot missiles ourselves? On July 8, Trump personally told Zelenskyy, we will give you a license to make Patriot. Three weeks later, it was a different story. We must be careful about whom we give the license to. And at the end of October, instead of permission, the Pentagon sent Ukraine's request for further review. So, whether it is possible to make these missiles ourselves remains an open question?

Speaker 2

Is it possible? Absolutely. Why not? It can happen. Will the Americans go for it? This is a very complex story and philosophy about Japan. If the Japanese already have, de facto, permission to produce such weapons, we have already discussed this. If this happens, it will actually be a colossal, huge success for us. And here, one must look not only at the technological part, but at the political, ideological, and even historical ones. Why? In the long run, manufacturers of such weapons always want their production capacities, even if it is licensed weaponry, to be protected. To put it in simple terms, what does this mean? We are finally, definitively, and hopefully forever and irrevocably breaking away from the Russian Federation as a failed empire. And personally, I hold the position that the entire technological school we received from them, especially in terms of weapon construction, should be slowly, bit by bit, discarded into the historical drain. This is the correct path. As for how it will be in reality, we must wait for concrete results, but there is one more very interesting aspect. Truly, one can only export that which has already worked in battle. That's just how it is. When news reaches us—in what amount of time, I don't even know—that the first licensed Patriot missile shot down some aerial attack, that's when we will say that this direction worked and that everything that was declared was truly successful. And personally, I hold the position that we should not just wait until some weapons are handed over to us; we need to purchase them ourselves. Here, in some parts, for example, we should take from the Poles. When the Russian-Ukrainian war flared up, the Poles adequately assessed the situation, and at this moment, quality weapons from, say, South Korea are already reaching them. Starting from tanks and ending, in my view, with the excellent KF-21 aircraft, which is a kind of analog to the F-35. Why is it that American weapons have a certain peculiarity? After the Islamic Revolution took place in Iran in 1979, and there remained—I think a squadron, I don't remember exactly—of the wonderful F-14 Tomcat aircraft, the Americans realized that they do not control this weaponry. And they build all modern weapons in such a way that they can disable them and they cannot work. This applies to the F-16, this applies to the MIM-104 Patriot, this applies to the HIMARS launcher itself; therefore, one really needs to look towards both our own development—I hope we will have the Freya system—as well as the purchase of other weapons, and personally, I stand for wide cooperation.

Speaker 1

Project Freya is a bold ambition to shake off dependence on the States and take its own defense into its own hands. The main mission is to create an anti-aircraft missile system that will effectively shoot down targets, including ballistic missiles, using a mass-produced and, most importantly, significantly cheaper alternative to PAC-3 missiles.

Speaker 2

And indeed, another surface-to-air missile system that may appear on European soil, of exactly such specifications—and what are these specifications—ballistics up to 60 and other aerial means 120-160 km, will be useful. Why? The Europeans have realized that they do not have enough systems. Of course, IRIS-T has proven itself fantastically, brilliantly, but that's up to 50 km. NASAMS has proven itself fantastically, brilliantly, but that is short-range. And SAMP/T, despite working well, let's say, against cruise missiles, has not proven itself in terms of ballistics. There is also a very important concept called combat testing. We are undergoing combat testing. We are going through it. We already have a certain design concept, but most importantly, we have the desire. We want to work on this. And it would be, in my view, a huge sin not to take advantage of this, at a time when the Europeans themselves are inviting us to great cooperation. I remind you that the more of those little knots, threads, and streams that will unite us with the great Euro-Atlantic space in the technological part, the better. We are establishing ourselves as a great military power. We are entering the club of prestigious states; for example, in terms of ballistics, there are only 15 countries in the world that can do this, and we are among them. And this, for instance, is very good.

Unknown speaker

Subtitle editor M. Shchurova Proofreader A. Kulakova


Don't forget to donate, Ukraine's cause is ours! Support Ukraine!

Originaltitel: Зброя 80-х, яка змінила хід війни: Patriot – світ знову б'ється за цей ЗРК і до чого тут Україна?

Längd: 20:27

Scroll to Top