Valerii Pekar: why are mass unemployment and a labor shortage threatening Ukraine simultaneously?
The material examines the Ukrainian labor market's challenges, including personnel shortages and skill gaps, while emphasizing human-centricity and a win-win mindset to foster economic recovery.
Speaker 1
We have despised the military for many years. They will believe that they gave Ukraine everything they could, but Ukraine did not repay them. Already 28.5 million have left their idea in Ukraine. Ukraine is a country of very leftist sentiments. The vast majority of Ukrainians, roughly 80%, perceive the world in terms of "win-lose". First, one must demand everything from the state, and only then from oneself. Perhaps they will think that one day they need to do the opposite. To be honest, one could already just give up and say it all. Nothing good will happen here, one can pack up, because everything has burned down anyway. Ukrainian men and women traditionally have a very poor attitude toward entrepreneurs. As a result, we will live in a situation where we have massive unemployment and a massive number of unfilled vacancies.
Speaker 2
We are now going to speak with our guest, Valerii Pekar. He is an entrepreneur and a public figure. Is it even possible to demand responsibility from a person toward the state if the state itself is not always responsible toward them?
Speaker 1
You know, first of all, every Ukrainian city has its own peculiarities. The way the war is felt in Kharkiv and the way it is felt in Odesa—even though, in essence, both cities are now frontline cities—is very different, because Kharkiv has seen the enemy for a long time, while Odesa sees the enemy from afar, and this affects perception. And even more so the cities that are further from the front line, and even more so Kyiv, which has now turned into a front line. Those cities in western Ukraine, every city has its own peculiarities. Second, everything is changing. The situation is changing dynamically, and the things that worried us six months ago no longer worry us, while other things arise. We literally recently completed a major study of the future using the foresight methodology: the labor market of Ukraine 2026-2036. The labor market is a complex thing. It is clear to everyone listening to us that the labor market relates to demographics, migration, productivity, investments, well-being, and everything. And it turned out there are three key forks that determine the scenarios for our future in this area. And the first key fork is the shortage of people. Where to get people? Recently Ella Libanova, our leading demographer, said that only 28.5 million people remained in Ukraine. All employers—and I was literally last Friday at a meeting of the 200 largest employers in Ukraine, which was a meeting of four leading business clubs of Ukraine from Kyiv, Lviv, Dnipro, and Odesa—spoke about the shortage of people. And the study showed that actually—remember last year—Russian propaganda conducted a brilliant information special operation when we were frightened by migrants who were simply standing at the border, 100-500 million migrants, and they would now cross the border and simply displace these Ukrainians, and that's it. By the way, this is the first successful operation of the Russian special services over all the years of the full-scale war that was actually able to convince, I would say, millions of Ukrainians that everything had already gone bad. This is, actually, on the one hand, good that Ukrainians are sufficiently resistant to propaganda, but on the other hand, it seems they managed to break through us, they found a weak spot. I want to say that key employers specifically do not view labor migrants as a solution. This is not an option that is on the table, because everything is very simple. I will speak very pragmatically. They tried, it didn't work. It turns out that it doesn't work that way. And it turns out that the key problem when we talk about the shortage of people is the problem that a huge number of Ukrainians are outside the labor market. These are older people; all these people could work, they want to work. Employers want to hire them. But there are barriers—legal, physical, psychological, organizational—that do not allow it. These are older people, 60 plus, for example. These are younger people, those who are still forbidden by law to work, but they already could and want to. These are mothers who cannot find a nanny; this is a huge cohort in Ukraine. These are people with disabilities, neurodivergent people, veterans who people are still afraid to hire because they don't really understand how to hire them, as they live by certain myths and work with them. This is a large share of people outside the labor market, that is number one. The second problem is a gap in competencies, a lack of competence. New technologies require more competencies. AI-robotization, automation can close the gap in human resources, increase productivity, but they require new skills even more—where are they to be found? As a result, we will live in a situation where we have huge unemployment and a huge number of unfilled vacancies. Because those people who cannot find work and those jobs that are vacant and for which people cannot be found do not correspond to each other, and people are unable to learn. And here we come to the third fork. And the third fork looks like what is called human-centricity. Look at what is happening. A huge number of people have left Ukraine. The war is ending; let's hope it will be sooner rather than later. For now, it's hard to talk about, but when the war ends, people will either return or not return. Those people who live in Ukraine will either leave Ukraine—for example, for family reunification—or not leave. Families will reunite one way or another; they will just reunite either here or there. And those same veterans, some of them may leave because they will feel that they gave Ukraine everything they could, but Ukraine did not reward them. And the key point here is precisely human-centricity. Human-centricity means that the country is attractive to people, in simple terms. In very simple terms. It is pleasant and comfortable to live and work here.
Speaker 2
Well, how can you do this after so many years of full-scale war?
Speaker 1
I want to start from the bottom level. After all, it was a foresight study on the labor market. That is, human-centricity begins at the workplace. Specifically for this person, specifically here, in this team, specifically with these bosses, it is comfortable to work, psychologically comfortable, this person is respected. Is there human dignity here? In other words, everything starts at the workplace. Second, communities. Employers can, for example, create a lot of jobs for people with disabilities, differences, and so on and so forth. But if these people cannot reach these workplaces, employers are no longer responsible for that. I understand that communities and states would now like to pin everything on employers, on entrepreneurs. Now everyone is required to have their own shelters, and also, as they joke in Kyiv, a little more, and employers will be forced to build their own bridges across the Dnipro so that workers can get to work. And air defense, actually, one must have now. Business should focus on creating jobs and generating profit, producing goods and services, not on defending the sky. So, it starts with the workplace, home, community, and then the country. That is, we tend to generalize very strongly, and this drives us into pessimism. Because how can we change the country? Well, the country is large, it is impossible to change. But in reality, one must start from the bottom up. And this is one of the main conclusions of the research I am talking about.
Speaker 2
I was in Lozova yesterday; there is a 30% shortage of municipal workers there. I don't remember what percentage there, but there are very many vacancies in the hospital. And even despite the fact that they offer housing even to doctors, they cannot attract them, because a large part of the doctors are, of course, in the military, yes, but a significant part have also left. And how then to address this right now?
Speaker 1
Let's take an extreme case of a settlement that is very close to the line of combat engagement. And let's look at Western Ukraine. And we will see that nearby there are cities in which communities are growing, and cities in which communities are shrinking. This is not a cultural difference; it is the same cultural zone. What is the problem? Obviously, local leaders are doing something differently, obviously, local communities are doing something differently, right? That is where we should look. Why do so many people live in Kharkiv and not leave?
Speaker 2
Well, this is our home.
Speaker 1
But we see very different dynamics in Ukrainian cities. And all this dynamics cannot be explained solely by security. Human-centricity does not begin with the fact that someone there can do it. You know, there is one of the key principles of management called internal locus of control. What is it about? It is about seeking answers to all the main questions within oneself. That is, to start making lists of what needs to be done, not based on a list of what they should do, but based on a list of what I should do. And this is an exercise that we are very bad at. Because that's how we've become accustomed. We are used to first making lists for them. Then you realize that they will not carry out these lists. And then the weeping and wailing begins, and complaints about those who there do not want to do what is wanted here. I understand that it is unpleasant to start with oneself. But, in reality, human-centricity begins with the houses in which we live, the workplace where we work, the street, the community, and so on. And then it moves further to the country. Therefore, a lot can be changed here.
Speaker 3
This is an idea, it's about a fairly large stratum of society of conscious citizens. There have never been very many of them. Even in times of social upheavals.
Speaker 1
It is not as if there are only those good community activists who give their time, resources, effort, and health to the country, and bad draft-dodgers who, on the contrary, do everything only for themselves and so on. These are two extreme ends of the spectrum, and between them is roughly 50% of the population, who are neither activists nor draft-dodgers. And from these 50%, activists draw their resources and new activists are cultivated, while on the other hand, some of them move to the side of the draft-dodgers. That is, we have half of Ukraine's citizens who have not yet finally decided who they are and what they are for. And it is to them that we are actually speaking. And if 10 people from this cohort hear us today and think that it would probably be a good idea to somehow get together and tidy up their building along with other residents, well, then that's a plus; we don't live in a world where everyone is clearly divided into black and white. There is a vast gray zone where people are in a process of development; people are not sealed containers—all people, and you and I are no exception, are in a process of development throughout their lives. And these people too, they will listen to us, they will hear—I very much hope they listen to Radio Hartiya at least occasionally—and perhaps some doubt will arise in their hearts about the idea that one must first demand everything from the state, and only then from oneself. Perhaps they will think that for once, they should do the opposite.
Speaker 2
Mr. Valerii, you know, I wanted to talk about something else as well—about entrepreneurs, about business owners. Doesn't it seem to you that they sometimes take advantage of the situation?
Speaker 1
It doesn't seem so, because as of today, Ukrainian business is, in essence, on the brink of survival. We understand that Ukrainian business must now factor into its costs both the possibility that a warehouse with all the goods will be lost, and the possibility that workers who do not have reservations will be dismissed and go to serve in the army. And the possibility that something will hit and everything will burn down, and many other things. And now the authorities have also obliged them to build shelters. Well, imagine a kiosk at a crossroads selling coffee, and today it must also build a shelter. For example, to understand the situation with warehouses, half of them remained in Ukraine after the latest shelling. That is, we understand, this means that entrepreneurs are ready—I return again to last Friday, when I was at a large meeting of the 200 largest entrepreneurs—entrepreneurs are ready to continue. These are the people thanks to whom Ukraine actually holds on today, just as it holds on thanks to the defense forces. These are people who continue to keep the economic wheels turning, continue to pay taxes, continue to maintain jobs, although, honestly, one could have already spat on it all and said "everything, nothing good will come of this, we can wind up, because everything burned down anyway." They will simply rebuild logistics, build new things, think through new processes, use the high level of digitalization to reorganize all flows. But from the speeches of these people—and over 100 people spoke there—I heard a unanimous readiness to continue developing Ukraine. Will they hear gratitude from the people? I think not. Because Ukrainian men and women traditionally view entrepreneurs very poorly. I believe that entrepreneurs are all people who take advantage of opportunities. Look, in our time, we undervalued doctors. We didn't respect doctors until COVID began. COVID began and we suddenly realized that doctors are people who are needed by the country. For many years, we despised the military. Like, who are they, doing who-knows-what there. They looked like simple marginals until the war began. The war began, and we began to respect the military. I very much hope the day will come when we start respecting teachers. I don't know if I am very learned, but I hope so. And I very much want us to live to see the day when we will respect entrepreneurs. Because we understand that Ukraine is a country of very leftist sentiments. A country in which an entrepreneur is considered a person who, by default, likely has low moral qualities. Because a normal person with high moral standing, obviously, would not engage in business. Because people, the vast majority of Ukrainians, roughly 80%, think of the world in the category of "win-lose." Win-lose, and this means one won, another lost. And this means that if you are an entrepreneur and became rich, it means you simply took money from a huge number of people. Here, by the way, I want to say that the same story happened. Western Ukraine was one of the poorest corners of Europe between the First and Second World Wars. But in one generation, thanks to the sermons and activities of Metropolitan Andrey Sheptytsky, who instilled the "win-win" mindset—that we can help one another together and together become better. Not only through sermons, but also through the institutions he created. This corner flourished so much that when the Muscovites came in 1939, they asked the Galicians the same sacramental question they asked the residents of the Kyiv region in the spring of 2022. How was it that you lived so well? Therefore, the "win-win" mindset is possible in Ukraine, and in Kharkiv, it seems to me, it must be very deeply rooted, because the entire history of Kharkiv is the history of a city where people always built "win-win." And this means treating entrepreneurs with respect, treating the people who create "win
Speaker 2
– win». Thank you, Valeriy. In our studio is Valeriy Pekar, an entrepreneur, a public figure.
Don't forget to donate, Ukraine's cause is ours! Support Ukraine!
